Political Analysis: The Nelson Picks
So, I don't want to make anybody panic/celebrate/react prematurely, but I've finished my picks for tomorrow's election. And here's how I think it could shake out:
McCain 270
Obama 268
What's that you say? I KNOW. Not at all the way that the media says it's going to turn out. I'm just a simple small-town momma and not a political analyst by trade, so obviously I may be wrong. But in case you're wondering, here's how I arrived at the numbers:
- I ignored the potential impact of the money and effort spent on this campaign and looked solely at the way in which a state voted over the past four Presidential elections. I'm interested to see if States really do vote in generally the same way that they always do, or if the estimated $1 Billion spent on this election really does have an impact.
- Out of the 51 areas that have votes in the Electoral College (Side note for anyone who is wondering if they missed another State being added to the Union while they were busy changing diapers and making ANOTHER run to Target: Yes, there are still only 50 States. The District of Columbia also has representation in the Electoral College, making the total areas represented 51), 36 States/+District have voted the same way in each of the last four elections. For example, if they have been Blue for the last four elections, I left them Blue for this one.
- That leaves 15 States where in some of the past four elections the state has been Red, and in some it has been Blue. For example, if there was a majority (mostly Red), I marked them down as Red for this election. Or if they were most recently Red, then I figured that if they have consistently voted for President Bush, perhaps they'd feel settled in their Red ways.
- Of those 15, there were only two States that varied from this approach - Colorado and New Mexico. After reading about recent polls in those States, I used the method called "gut reaction" to place my picks.
Want the details? Want to follow along with my picks as you watch the results rolling in? Download the official Nelson Picks.
Want to argue with me? Tell me how wrong I am? Yell at me for posting such projections? Or, maybe you're thrilled to see the numbers aligned in this way? Is there anyone who reads this site that feels that way (other than you, Dad and Marty)? Feel free to leave your thoughts here, or come back later and hand me an "I told you so".
Trust me, I don't mind being wrong. Just ask my husband.

Wow! I admire your logic. You have become a real analyst.
Reply to this
The GOP BETTER get in there! I'm proud to show my Red, White and Blue at this point in our country. We NEED a solid person that has the military balls to finish what's been started in Iraq.....and I don't care if that means bringing them home. As long as it comes from McCain! GOP that's all I can say.....now let's see how long it takes Jennie to remove my comment from her site!
Reply to this
Remember that time on our second date when you told me that you were a Democrat? Oh, that was so funny!
Reply to this
Really funny, actually!
Reply to this
I agree with you Jennie, I think this is how it will play out too.
Marty, Jennie won't remove your comment, but good to hear you fired up! We'll have to talk tomorrow!
Reply to this
Jennie
I am so proud of Mrs. O'Brien
Reply to this
Need me to fill in the Canadian provinces? Just kidding. I don't know how your election will turn out, but I know it will be exciting. I think you actually have two really good candidates (for President) this time. It will be interesting to see how things pan out as our economy is so closely knit with yours.
Reply to this
Yikes. I can only hope that you are wrong Jennie. Your analysis, makes real good sense.
Reply to this
Do you have a MN state election analysis? How's Al Franken going to come out? I think if he wins he should mandate daily affirmations every morning before leaving the house.
Reply to this
Best idea of the day Carrie!
Reply to this